Even as pay transparency becomes more common, many early-career candidates still accept their first salary offer without negotiating. This hesitation can have long-term effects for employees as well as employers trying to close offers quickly and reduce reneges.
Many early-career candidates still accept the first salary they are offered without negotiating. Even with more pay transparency, that hesitation shapes starting salaries and what happens next. For employers, it affects how quickly offers close and whether top hires stick around.
What the Data Shows
Why It Happens
Entry-level hires often worry they will lose the offer if they ask for more. Some feel they do not have enough information to back up the request. Others simply feel awkward bringing up salary at the end of the process.
When hiring managers are unprepared to answer questions about pay, trust breaks down fast. Candidates who feel shut down or unclear are more likely to shop for other offers or accept a counter elsewhere.
What It Costs
This hesitation does not just affect the candidate’s paycheck. It affects your pipeline and retention. A new hire who feels underpaid or unheard is more likely to leave early or talk about the process with peers.
When companies rely on old pay bands or handle negotiations inconsistently, they create gaps that can grow over time. Early-career employees who do not negotiate now often see those gaps widen as they move up.
Early Offers Make the Difference
Top-paying industries are securing top talent sooner by compressing timelines. Many extend offers well before graduation. For sectors where salaries are not the highest, speed and transparency can keep you in the game.
Strong early offers:
What Employers Can Do
Negotiation is one moment you can handle well or poorly. How you manage it shapes how candidates feel about your process and whether they accept your offer with confidence.
Here are ways employers are helping early-career candidates navigate negotiation:
Handling negotiation well does more than close one hire. It sets the tone for how candidates see your company, how likely they are to share positive feedback, and whether they stick around long enough to grow with you.
Note: These insights reflect early reporting as of May 1, 2025. Actual final outcomes may shift as additional data is collected and verified throughout the year.
See how Hiring Cloud keeps you competitive and informed.
